Diagnosis and posttreatment follow-up of Helicobacter pylori-positive gastric lymphoma of mucosa-associated lymphoid tissue: histology, polymerase chain reaction, or both?

The differential diagnosis between Helicobacter pylori (H pylori-associated chronic gastritis and low-grade B-cell gastric lymphoma of mucosa-associated lymphoid tissue (MALT) and the assessment of endoscopic biopsy specimens after treatment of lymphoma can be problematic. Although immunocytochemistry can be used to identify clonal B-cell populations, which are characteristic of MALT lymphoma, its application to small biopsy specimens and the subsequent interpretation can be difficult. The polymerase chain reaction (PCR) can detect clonal B-cell populations by analysis of the Ig heavy chain gene in routinely fixed paraffin-embedded material and might provide a useful tool in the assessment of these specimens. We have investigated the value of histology and PCR in the diagnosis of lymphoma and its followup in formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded gastric endoscopy biopsy specimens from 69 sequential patients selected on the basis of a dense mucosal lymphoid infiltrate associated with H pylori infection. Histologic evidence of MALT lymphoma was identified in 13 cases, 9 of which showed PCR-detected monoclonality. In 12 of 13 cases, H pylori was eradicated, and in 11 of 12 cases, histologic regression of the lymphoma followed. PCR evidence of monoclonality disappeared in 6 of 9 originally monoclonal cases. This was synchronous with histologic remission in 1 case, but lagged in the remaining 5 cases by up to 28 months. Two of the 3 of the 9 cases originally monoclonal by PCR that have not shown molecular regression have monoclonal-amplified products 17 and 24 months after negative histology. In 3 cases, the histology of the biopsies was considered indeterminate or discordant. In 1 of these cases, the histologic features were obscured by crush artefact. In a second case, there was molecular evidence of monoclonality in the absence of histologic features suggestive of lymphoma; this persisted after H pylori eradication. An additional single case originally diagnosed as reactive developed a PCR detectable clonal population 29 months after original evaluation in the absence of histologic features of lymphoma but in the presence of persistent H pylori infection. These findings suggest that the histologic assessment of gastric biopsies remains the method of choice for the diagnosis of lymphoma in gastric endoscopic biopsies with a dense mucosal lymphoid infiltrate. PCR provides a useful technique to support the diagnosis if clonal amplification products are found. The significance of PCR detected clonality in the absence of histologic evidence of lymphoma in uncertain but may represent a stage of tumor progression/regression when the clonal population is insufficient to be detected by conventional histology. This is supported by the evidence that PCR-detectable monoclonality can persist after treatment and the disappearance of histologically detectable lymphoma.